As I was responding I received an update and it became clear that more assets were needed: Clearview Fire & Emergency Services personnel are trained to awareness level for technical rescue; Barrie Fire & Emergency Service provides our municipality with technical-rescue technicians through a service agreement.
Clearview Fire responded with Chief 1, Pumper 52, Tanker 53, Squad 45, Rescue 14 with ATV 1, and 14 firefighters.
Crew 53, Rescue 14, Ontario Provincial Police and County of Simcoe Paramedics arrived at 9:09 p.m. at the location – about 1.5 kilometres through a narrow walking trail from the road – via multiple trips aboard ATV 1, a 2014 Kubota two-seater tracked vehicle.
Initial reports were confirmed – an individual was about 12 metres (40 feet) down and six metres (20 feet) horizontally trapped underground in the Nottawasaga Bluffs Conservation area.
The man was discovered by two hikers who heard his voice and were able to identify his location, call 911, notify his wife, and direct first responders to the scene.
The individual’s wife directed fire crews in from a south location; the crew from Squad 45 and paramedics walked 20 minutes through the trails with medical bags and equipment and met up with the crew from Rescue 14 and ATV 1, which had entered from a north location.
The responding crews on ATV 1 and Tank 53 made patient contact and attempted to lower water down the crevasse but that was unsuccessful. One Clearview firefighter maintained constant contact with paramedics.
The firefighters investigated alternate entrances to the crevasse and, as darkness was falling, rescuers began to shuttle in equipment and lighting.
Barrie Fire & Emergency Service arrived at 9:33 p.m. with its technical-rescue members; Squad 1, Tanker 3, Brush Truck 1, an incident safety officer, and Deputy Chief Bill Boyes.
A rescue technician continued to talk with the patient, 30-year-old Seth Rowe, but crews were unable to reach him; the crevasse was too narrow – just 20 centimetres wide.
Crews were able to get water to the patient at 10:37 p.m. At this time, Barrie Fire requested more manpower and managed to get a rescue harness to the patient.
As Barrie Fire’s technical-rescue members worked in the hot zone, at 11:38 p.m., Clearview Fire members picked up equipment from Stayner Rental (the owner had been contacted and had returned to his business from his cottage) – portable heaters, propane tanks and hose to get heat down in crevasse; light did not reach the depths of the crevasse and there was snow and ice in the patient’s area.
Heaters were lowered and heat was delivered laterally by hoses to the patient, along with more water and energy bars.
The rescue area was remote. As I travelled on the Kubota ATV the headlights showed our way through the winding walking trails, the starry sky disappeared under the tall, lush trees, and LED lights appeared in the distance, with glow sticks marking the end of the trail like an airport landing strip.
Generators hummed and the smell of a camp fire filled the air – the patient’s wife and the two hikers who found the individual in the crevasse were huddled around it.
Accountability was established and tarps were set up for staging equipment. Each person on scene had a specific duty.
iPads were used on scene to monitor weather; there was rain in the forecast for early morning so tents and tarps were set up to protect the patient from elements.
Throughout the night an open line of communication was maintained with the wife and the hikers regarding the status of the rescue, and CTV Barrie was given permission to document the rescue story from a safe distance.
Barrie Fire had managed to raise the patient several feet but couldn’t bring him up any further, and medics were concerned about his well-being due to the cold.
In collaboration with Deputy Boyes from Barrie, additional technical-rescue resources were requested at 3:32 a.m. from Toronto Fire Services through the Provincial Emergency Operation Centre (PEOC).
Toronto sent two rescue squads – Pumper 143 and Squad 143 – with eight personnel (some are members of Toronto’s Heavy Urban Search and Rescue team and happened to be on shift), along with Deputy Chief Matt Pegg; they arrived on scene at 5:30 a.m. and led the rescue with Barrie Fire in the hot zone.
Captains Chris Rowland and Chuck Guy, both HUSAR team members, did a size-up and all three agencies met to co-ordinate next steps: Toronto Fire (rescue sector), Barrie Fire (rescue sector) and Clearview Fire (incident command – operations, logistics, planning).
Incident command ran meetings every half hour to determine progress and patient condition. Paramedic Chief Andrew Robert organized supervisors and advanced-care paramedics with an off-road patient-transport vehicle.
During the rescue, food from Tim Hortons in nearby Stayner was brought to the scene. ATV 1 completed 60 trips to shuttle equipment and personnel to and from the location; this vehicle logged 185 kilometres on off-road trails.
During the extrication attempt, Rowland – a rescue-sector officer, rescue specialist and squad leader for Toronto’s HUSAR team – would yell, “Quiet,” at which time all generators and talking ceased; this enabled rescuers to hear the patient and communicate to him their next steps.
At 6:14 a.m., members of Toronto Fire and Barrie Fire began an aggressive extrication attempt with rock removal by air chisel; air bags were used to protect the patient. Clearview Fire supported with accountability and equipment operation.
Rescue technicians inverted into the crevasse and used the air chisel to expand its width. The space was too tight for crew members’ eight-inch Petzl helmets – “we couldn’t get our heads in so we knew we had to chisel,” Rowland explained. “The three guys who were down there were inverted and had one hand on the air chisel and chopped away in the rock to make a hole for him. It’s not something we practise all the time but it worked.”
Toronto Fire had set up another anchor and rigging plate to the left of the main crevasse, “and using Barrie’s rigging plate, we were able to bring him up,” Rowland said.
“We had both rigging systems working together – my guys running a lateral line to bring him to the left. Barrie had set up to bring him straight up and we needed to bring him to the left – the Bravo side. We had rigged another system and that’s where the teamwork came in – Barrie had to go slack on its line so we could bring him up on our side.”
Toronto Fire rescue technician Tim MacDonald made contact with the patient at 9:28 a.m., and the patient was extricated and in the care of paramedics at 9:41 a.m., 12 hours and 21 minutes after the emergency call was received.
Relief squads from Toronto Fire and Ontario Mine Rescue – notified via the PEOC – had been called proactively; they were stood down en route upon notification that the patient had been extricated.
A scribe had also been called to take notes had the operation continued, and Simcoe County fire co-ordinator Dan Heydon was updated throughout the rescue.
All rescue crews and emergency personnel cleared the emergency scene at about 12:30 p.m.
Essentially, Rowland said, the Clearview and Barrie crews were able to extend the patient’s viability by getting heat, water and food to him, which then enabled the technical crew to complete the rescue.
“They did enough to extend that golden hour, and all we had to do was extract him,” Rowland said. “It’s all about the timeline for us – timing is everything – if you can buy us more time we can affect any rescue; we can get to the guy. They got heat to him, food to him and that kept him strong and when he was ready we got him up.
“It was real positive co-ordination among the teams and everyone felt really good about doing a good job and pulling this guy out.”
An ideal outcome
This incident brought together volunteer firefighters, career firefighters, communicators, paramedics, civilians and community businesses to achieve a great outcome.
The knowledge, training and expertise of the fire service technical-rescue teams is both obvious and impressive: Barrie and Toronto Fire worked side by side, in a seamless and impeccably co-ordinated manner, on the scene of a very complicated and complex rescue emergency.
This incident is a powerful reminder of the importance of professional qualification standards and standardized training.
NFPA 1006 is the professional qualification standard for technical rescue and the fact that Barrie and Toronto train to the same professional qualifications make it possible for them to work together without having to navigate differences in philosophy, training, equipment, tactics and operations.
As the only emergency-response agency with a mandate for rescue, it is imperative that the fire service in Ontario continues to drive the transition to the NFPA professional qualifications aggressively. This incident is clear testament to the value of standardized, professional training.
This incident also clearly highlights how effectively the incident command system can be expanded as an incident escalates.
Technical rescue teams – and HUSAR teams – operate as sectors within the framework of the existing incident command system. Incoming senior officers – in this case deputy chiefs Boyes and Pegg – were able to immediately provide assistance to the incident commander. Boyes and Pegg assumed responsibility for communicating with outside agencies that included the PEOC, Office of the Fire Marshal and Emergency Management, and Toronto Fire, which at one point assembled additional rescue equipment for deployment to Clearview in the event that operations were going to be extended.
- with files from Matt Pegg and Laura King
View the embedded image gallery online at:
Barrie Fire Control receives word that a hiker is trapped in the Nottawasaga Bluffs Conservation Area
Clearview Fire & Emergency Services arrives on scene
Ontario Provincial Police, County of Simcoe Paramedics and additional Clearview Fire personnel arrive
Barrie Fire & Emergency Service arrives with a technical-rescue team
Crews are able to get water and a rescue harness to the patient and Barrie Fire requests more manpower
Clearview Fire picks up portable heaters, propane tanks and hose to get heat down in crevasse
Additional technical-rescue resources are requested from Toronto Fire Services through PEOC
Two rescue squads and eight personnel from Toronto Fire arrive on scene
Members of Toronto Fire and Barrie Fire begin an aggressive extrication with an air chisel
Toronto Fire rescue technician Tim MacDonald makes contact with the patient
Patient is extricated and in care of paramedics
All rescue personnel clear the scene
■ Clearview Fire & Emergency Services
- Five stations
- 100 paid-on-call firefighters
- Full-time Chief Colin Shewell and Deputy Chief Roree Payment
- Part-time administrator, fire-prevention officer,
- training officer
- 12 fire apparatuses, one ATV and three support vehicles
- 650 calls a year
■ Barrie Fire & Emergency Service
- Five stations
- 144 full-time firefighters; five training officers, 13 communication operators, seven fire-prevention officers, one public fire and life-safety educator, five administrative staff, three deputy chiefs and one chief
- Seven front-line apparatuses, Marine 1, one hazmat and one technical-rescue apparatus, Brush 1, and incident-safety officer and platoon-chief vehicles along with a number of staff and support vehicles
- Approximately 8,000 calls per year
■ Toronto Fire Services
- Largest fire service in Canada
- 83 stations
- 28 public educators, 159 fire prevention officers, 2,670 operations firefighters (officers included), 73 call-takers/dispatchers, 46 mechanics, 31 training officers, six public information officers, 138 admin/support services staff, five deputy chiefs and one chief
- Canada Task Force 3 – HUSAR
- 124 front-line apparatuses
- More than 111,000 calls per year