Leadership: Leading by example – when to wear your SCBA
By Barry Bouwsema
Protecting the respiratory system is an essential component of a
firefighter’s personal protective equipment. Firefighters and fire
officers are required to wear positive pressure self-contained
breathing apparatus to protect themselves from carbon monoxide and
other toxins found in smoke, such as hydrogen cyanide, formaldehyde,
acrolein, hydrogen chloride, toluene, sulphur dioxide, nitrogen
dioxide, isocyanates ... the list goes on.
By Barry Bouwsema
Protecting the respiratory system is an essential component of a firefighter’s personal protective equipment. Firefighters and fire officers are required to wear positive pressure self-contained breathing apparatus to protect themselves from carbon monoxide and other toxins found in smoke, such as hydrogen cyanide, formaldehyde, acrolein, hydrogen chloride, toluene, sulphur dioxide, nitrogen dioxide, isocyanates … the list goes on.
Respiratory protection should be considered mandatory for all firefighters and fire officers operating in hazardous environments. It should be a fundamental rule in fire fighting that no one is permitted to enter a potentially dangerous atmosphere (toxic, oxygen deficient, elevated temperature, dangerous goods events, etc.) without protective breathing apparatus.
CO is a killer
Carbon monoxide (CO) is a by-product of incomplete combustion, is present at essentially all fire scenes, and is a well recognized risk at all structure fires. This toxic fire gas is responsible for more fire deaths than from any other product of combustion. A recent study from Yale University (2004)1 tested several interior firefighting scenes where firefighters were working to assess the degree of possible CO exposure. The study found that the ambient CO readings for the fire attack evolutions ranged from 75 to 1,290 ppm (IDHL is 1200 ppm). The need for respiratory protection was evident.
It is not uncommon for firefighters to remove their SCBA during the overhaul evolution. This can be a dangerous practice. The Yale University study recorded ambient CO levels during overhaul procedures to range from 0 to 130 ppm (PEL is 50 ppm). A previous study conducted by the American Industrial Hygiene Association (2000) demonstrated that CO levels exceeded the NIOSH STEL of 200 ppm during overhaul at five of 25 fires studied2. It is therefore possible that firefighters are being subjected to clinically significant levels of CO during fire overhaul evolutions. This occupational health concern can easily be avoided through the proper application and use of SCBA. A fireground commander cannot tolerate any unsafe condition; this includes personnel safety during the overhaul of the fire scene.
Keep yourself safe
Failure to or choosing not to wear the appropriate safety gear can often be attributed to one of three factors: needs, attitude or ability. The aspect of needs includes such items as the availability of SCBA. Insisting that SCBA be worn can only work if the needed equipment is available. Fortunately, in today’s fire service, SCBAs are readily available. The aspect of ability includes proper training and the necessary knowledge and skills in the use of the safety equipment. Any shortfalls in this area must be addressed through an appropriate training program. Finally, the aspect of attitude includes personal preferences and beliefs. Some firefighters may still cling to the dated “smoke-eater” mentality. Scientific research clearly demonstrates that today’s fires generate smoke laden with toxins and carcinogens. Personal preferences as to when to use a SCBA are best addressed through well written department SOPs.
Research suggests that morbidity and morality from smoke inhalation CO poisoning is preventable. When in doubt, respiratory protection should be utilized by all fireground personnel, including the fire officer. Leadership often means leading by example, so gear up!
1 Cone, D. et al. (2004). Noninvasive Fireground Assessment of Carboyhemoglobin Levels in Firefighters. Prehospital Emergency Care J. 2005; 9(1), 8-13.
2 Bolstad-Johnson DM (2000). Characterization of firefighter exposures during fire overhaul. AIHA J. 2000;61:636-41.
Barry Bouwsema is a company officer for Strathcona County Emergency Services, Sherwood Park, Alta. He has been in the fire service for 20 years, and is a graduate of Athabasca University with a Bachelor’s degree in General Studies. He lectures paramedic students at the Northern Alberta Institute of Technology and teaches firefighters (NFPA 1001) at the Emergency Services Academy.