Smoke alarm safety
By Len Garis and Karin Mark
New research has reinforced what the Canadian fire service already knows from experience – working smoke alarms provide a crucial early warning that helps to reduce the spread of fires.
By Len Garis and Karin Mark
The study, Smoke Alarm Response Time: Examining the Relationship Between Working Smoke Alarms, Fire Service Response Times and Fire Outcomes, was released in November by the University of the Fraser Valley in British Columbia.
Authors Joseph Clare, Charles Jennings and Len Garis examined 868 residential structure fires in B.C. from 2008 to 2018 to determine how working smoke alarms influence fire outcomes as compared to fire department response times. Time of day was also considered.
“The data show a clear pattern: the earlier that occupants know about a fire, the less likely it is to spread beyond the room of origin,” noted Clare, a criminology lecturer at the University of Western Australia and former strategic planning analyst for Surrey Fire Services in B.C. “Overall, the findings underscore the significant potential of smoke alarms to enhance residential building fire safety – particularly in areas where response times are a challenge.”
Based on the results, working smoke alarms reduce the likelihood of fires extending beyond the room of origin by more than 70 per cent – regardless of response time. As well, when no smoke alarm is present, the risk of fires spreading beyond the room of origin increases by 17 per cent for each additional minute it takes the fire department to respond.
Fires that occur during the day are also at least 60 per cent less likely to extend beyond the room of origin, and less likely to sustain large amounts of building loss.
The analysis focused on residential structure fires that occurred between March 2008 and April 2018 in the City of Surrey in Metro Vancouver, both with and without a working smoke alarm. Only fires related to residential structure fires and those with either working smoke alarms or no smoke alarms were selected.
Of 868 fires, 479 involved working smoke alarms and 389 had no smoke alarms on site. Response times were grouped into one-minute intervals.
The following picture emerged:
- For fires where smoke alarms were activated, the first unit almost always arrived on-scene in less than seven minutes (85-87 per cent of the time) and the last unit almost always arrived in less than 13 minutes (82-85 per cent of the time).
- Regardless of response time, the presence of a working smoke alarm significantly reduced the likelihood of fires spreading beyond the room of origin (71-72 per cent across the board).
- There was a significant relationship between the time of the fire and building damage. If a fire occurred during the day, the likelihood it would spread beyond the room of origin was reduced by 61-64 per cent. Daytime fires also had 41-47 per cent less building loss.
- There was a significant relationship between total response time and fire spread, with each one minute of response time increasing the odds of the fire extending beyond the room of origin by 17-18 per cent.
Additional analysis was undertaken to examine why fires involving smoke alarms were contained to the room of original more often, regardless of response time.
Based on prior research, the authors noted that it was reasonable to assume that this was the result of building occupants – having been alerted to the fire early – intervening to attack the fires before the fire department arrived. Additional analysis backed this up.
“From the perspective of the authors, the primary take-away is the importance of having a working smoke alarm at all residential properties,” noted Jennings, one of the authors and director of the Christian Regendhard Center for Emergency Response Studies at the John Jay College of Criminal Justice at the City University of New York.
The study can be downloaded at cjr.ufv.ca.
Len Garis is the fire chief for the City of Surrey, B.C., and an adjunct professor in the School of Criminology and Criminal Justice & associate to the Centre for Social Research at the University of the Fraser Valley (UFV). Contact him at Len.Garis@ufv.ca. Karin Mark writes for publications and provides communications and design services in Metro Vancouver, B.C.